S Corporations can be great. Pass-through taxation! Employment tax savings!! But those advantages can come with a few drawbacks. While folks who decide to operate their businesses through S corporations are typically aware of the restrictions required to make and maintain a valid S election (e.g., only 1 class of stock, shareholders can be only U.S. individuals, estates and certain types of trusts and charities), they often aren’t aware of some of the operational quirks of S corporations. Here’s our Top-6 List of Wait…what? I didn’t know that about my S corporation-isms.
- Not All S Corporation Elections for LLCs are Tax-Free – When you make an S election for an existing LLC / tax partnership, it may seem like you’re just filing a simple form, but in Tax World (aka The World’s Worst Amusement Park), the LLC transfers all of its assets and liabilities to a new corporation in exchange for shares and then distributes those shares to its members in liquidation. In a lot of cases, that’s a tax-free “351 exchange,” but if the LLC’s debt exceeds the LLC’s tax basis in its assets, that difference is taxable gain. Think of an LLC that borrowed funds to buy equipment, the entire cost of which was deducted under bonus depreciation (i.e., basis reduced to 0).
- Your LLC S Corporation’s Operating Agreement May Invalidate the S Election – You made an S election for your existing LLC / tax partnership but didn’t give a second thought to the LLC’s Operating Agreement sitting at the bottom of a drawer. If that Operating Agreement says that current distributions are made according to ownership percentages and liquidating distributions are made according to “Capital Accounts” (or has any other variation for distributions), the IRS says that creates a second class of stock and the S election was invalid (even if you ignored the agreement when you made distributions). But fret not, the IRS has an easy fix that doesn’t even require you to send anything to the IRS (see Rev.Proc. 2022-19)! It’s easy, but you have to do it before the IRS catches it.
- Distributions of Property Can Trigger Taxable Gain – Want to get back the company office building you contributed to the S corp 15 years ago or take title to the fully depreciated company car so your teenager can drive it to school? Not so fast! When an S corporation distributes built-in-gain property to its owner, the S corporation recognizes that gain as if it sold the property to the owner for FMV.
- No “Inside Basis” Step-Up on Death of a Shareholder – In a tax partnership, on the death of a partner, a “Section 754 election” can be made to step-up to FMV the partner’s share of “inside basis” of the partnership assets, so that when those assets are later sold, the built-in-gain at the time of death is not recognized by the successor partner. An S corporation may be pass-through, but it’s not a tax partnership, and there’s no similar election for S corps.
- Shareholders Do Not Get Tax Basis for S Corporation Debt – Unlike partners of a tax partnership, S corporation owners do not get tax basis in their S corp interest for S corp debt unless the owner is also the lender (guarantees don’t count). This means that an owner may not be able to take S corporation losses funded by that debt (e.g., from bonus depreciation) since losses are limited to the owner’s outside tax basis.
- The Road to QSBS is Rocky – Someone thinks your S corp business is amazing and wants to invest a bunch of money for an interest. But first, they need you to revoke the S election so they can acquire “Qualified Small Business Stock” (QSBS). For QSBS acquired after July 4, 2025, if a shareholder holds QSBS at least 5 years (and all other requirements are met), when the stock is sold, up to $15 million of gain (indexed for inflation) is tax-free! It’s one of the few good rides at Tax World, but it’s not so easy for the existing owners to board. QSBS has to be issued by a C corporation, but the existing owners got their stock from an S corporation and revoking the S election doesn’t change that. There are a couple of ways to get there (S corp holding company with asset transfer or multi-step “F Reorg” transaction), but it’s not simple.